Home » Cooperstown Trading Pins

Cooperstown Trading Pins

Free pin art. Free shipping.

Trading pin with gemstone accessory for the eye.
Example of Cooperstown Trading Pin
Trading pin with glitter accessory for name.
Cooperstown Trading Pin with dangler accessory example.
Trading pin with a dangler accessory.
Example of Cooperstown Trading Pin
Cooperstown Trading Pin with dangler accessory example.

Request a Free Design

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.


Step 1: Submit your idea. Picture shows a pencil sketch of a possible pin design.

Step 1: Submit Idea

Describe your idea. If you have one, upload an image. Receive your free pin design within hours!

Step 2: Receive your art. Picture shows a fully designed graphic of what the custom pin will look like.

Step 2: Receive Art

Review your custom pin design and request any changes you’d like. Enjoy unlimited revisions.

Step 3: Receive your pins. Picture shows the manufactured pin.

Step 3: Receive Pins

After approving a final design, complete the order with payment. Next, receive your pins fast!

NEED Cooperstown pins fast?

Get your Cooperstown team pins in as little as 1 business day!

We have a specialized manufacturing process that allows us to produce pins faster than anyone else. Simply enter the date you need them when ordering.

Up Your Game with These Accessories!

Your team’s pins will be the talk of Cooperstown with our unique interactive elements!

Blinker accessory example. A blinking red light is used for the mascots eyes on the pin.


For those with larger budgets, blinkers are a great way to attract attention.
(+ $0.95 each)

Slider accessory example. A baseball player slides to home base on the pin.


Slide to the right. Slide to the left. Nobody can resist playing with a slider!
(+ $0.65 each)

Spinner accessory example. A team mascot is spinning around on the pin.


Put a spin on your pins. Literally. Spinners come in different sizes. Call us for details.
(+ $0.55 each)

Dangler accessory example. A baseball mitt dangler swings back and forth on the bottom of the custom pin.


One of our most popular accessories, a small pin “dangles” from the main pin.
(+ $0.45 each)

Glitter accessory example. Fiery flames twinkle around a baseball on a custom pin design.


Glitter will add some style to your pins at a very affordable price.
(+ $0.12 each)

Custom lanyards example. A team's logo and artwork is printed onto the lanyard.


Get custom lanyards to hold all of the trading pins you’ve collected.
($80 for x100)


Unmatched in quality and experience.

Free Shipping in the USA

No hidden fees. Our pins come with free air shipping. Rush orders are also available at checkout.

Free Custom Artwork

Other sites require that you hire your own graphic designer. At Pins Fast, our talented artists will create your design for free.

15 Years of Quality

With 15 years of experience, our pins are crafted to be durable and each comes with a military grade attachment.

Recent Cooperstown Custom Pins

Pins Fast is one of the largest designers of custom pins for teams at Cooperstown tournaments. If you’ve attended in the past, then you’ve already seen trading pins from Pins Fast before!

Examples of some Cooperstown Trading Pins that we've designed.
Cooperstown Trading Pins
Examples of some Cooperstown Trading Pins that we've designed.
Cooperstown Trading Pins

Customer Reviews

Customers rate this product 5 out 5 stars (based on 37 reviews).

Showing Off Cooperstown

Rated 5.0 out of 5

WOW! We are totally thrilled and pleased at how great these look. We are confident that every player will be on the hunt for our pins to trade with our players. Looking forward to showing them off down in Cooperstown.

Avatar for Elaine B. - Mississauga Southwest Twins
Elaine B. – Mississauga Southwest Twins

Only Pins Fast was able to help

Rated 5.0 out of 5

When I called Pins Fast, I was so stressed because my son’s baseball team needed the pins for an upcoming tournament. I had called at least five other companies before finally reaching them and none of them were able to help me. None of them even tried. From the second Pins Fast answered the phone I could tell they were all about making it happen. It was never “no” and always “let me see what I can do”. And them made it happen. Anytime I need pins they will be my go to!!!

Avatar for Samantha G. - San Diego Stars Baseball
Samantha G. – San Diego Stars Baseball

Great trading experience

Rated 5.0 out of 5

I took one out for a sneak peak and will separate them out for the kids later tonight! Thank you so much for being our hero and saving the day! The kids are going to have a great trading experience with these pins!

Avatar for Kelli F. - Wayzata Squirt B1 Blue Hockey
Kelli F. – Wayzata Squirt B1 Blue Hockey

Only Use Pins Fast

Rated 5.0 out of 5

I received our pins. I cannot thank you enough for the help you and your team provided to me for my son’s team. I will only ever use your company for pins in the future, and I will be sure to tell everyone about your great work.

Avatar for Pam M. - Colorado Thunder Lightning Baseball
Pam M. – Colorado Thunder Lightning Baseball

1st Place in Trading Pin competition!

Rated 5.0 out of 5

I wanted to thank you for making us an amazing pin. Our school won 1st Place in the Club Trading Pin competition!!! Everyone loved the pin and asked for one! We will be competing at Nationals in June 2022 so I will be contacting you soon to order more pins! Thanks again from New Prospect School in Lawrenceburg, TN!!!!

Avatar for Christian R. - New Prospect School
Christian R. – New Prospect School

Extreme Rush Order Met

Rated 5.0 out of 5

Our team was in an extreme rush to order pins to exchange at a tournament. Pinsfast.com worked quickly, and in my opinion, over and above regular service to design, confirm, create and deliver our pins. The pins were delivered to our hotel at the tournament; great flexibility! The pin design had many features; the players and parents were thrilled! Thanks Pins Fast!

2014 TC Tremors-Harrison Team


Have a question? Find quick answers to common questions.

Rush order pins can be manufactured and shipped as fast as 1 business day. They will be delivered by FedEx to arrive on the date you enter at checkout.

Sure. When submitting your order, simply upload your image file and explain how you would like us to use it. You may also upload images of concepts or sketches of your idea and then we can convert it into a full-color graphic.

If you receive a quote first, then you will pay after you’ve approved a final version of your free pin design. There’s no commitment to buy when you request your custom pin design!

If you place your order first on our Instant Order page, you will pay at that time and a pin design will be sent to you shortly thereafter for your review.

If you want to add accessories to your pin design just mention that in the free design and quote form.

If you already received a free pin design and would like to add accessories, just click the big yellow button to “request a revision”.

Trading pins are usually Standard Soft Enamel pins. However, trading pins can be any of the styles below.

Soft Enamel: The soft enamel style is where the colors are separated by a metal line. Trading pins are usually Standard Soft Enamel pins. These metal pins have the design impressed into the metal. The recessed areas are then filled with enamel color. They’re vibrant and affordable

Hard Enamel: These are metal with enamel color. But unlike standard soft enamel pins, Standard Hard Enamel pins have a flat, polished finish.

Die Struck: Made by impressing (striking) the pin design into solid metal, Standard Die Struck pins usually have minimal or no color overlaid, so the metal color is the focus.

Offset Printed: Your design is printed onto a smooth, metal surface and overlaid with a clear glaze for protection. Offset printing allows for gradients and more intricate color (such as a photograph) than enamel pins.

Feel free to call us to discuss the pros and cons of each material type or to request a pin sample kit.

Have questions? Call us!

Available Monday-Friday, 8am-6pm EST.



Other Products - Soft Enamel Pins


Our most popular metal pin.

Other Products - Hard Enamel Pins


A smooth, polished surface.

Other Products - Trading Pins


For teams. Our specialty!

Other Products - Offset Printed Pins


For intricate coloring.